Les Paul vs. ES 335
Posted 16 August 2011 - 07:41 AM
I've got a really hard decision to make.
Finally I've got the money to buy a real Gibson, but I can't choose between the Les Paul Standard ('08) and the ES-335 DOT.
'Till this moment I love them both, and they both have their positives (and negatives).
Currently I own a Stratocaster, and I prefer rock, blues and pop songs.
I will take a look at both of them before I decide to buy one, but I would like to have your opinion about both guitars.
Which one would you pick or do you prefer? Why?
Posted 16 August 2011 - 08:40 AM
Posted 16 August 2011 - 09:17 AM
These forums IMO are slightly LP obsessed....
No doubt they satisfy many players' desire for cool looks and versatile sounds
For me, the 335 has a more classic look, harking back to the archtops of yore
Eric Clapton 'muddies the waters' somewhat by extracting great sounds from 335, LP and Strat
Personally I like big guitars to hold.....
Ideally one could have an extended trial of each before committing either way...no substitute for hands-on experience...
Lower and Warmer....
I like kayaking....it really floats my boat....
I dig most stuff....
Posted 16 August 2011 - 09:33 AM
Versatility is important for me. I'd like to buy a guitar that fit many styles or genres, not just one or a few.
And okay, they both look really cool. ES has a nice classic look, the Paul more of a rock look.
But there also is a difference in price. The ES (DOT) is a bit more affordable than the Les Paul.. That makes the desicion also pretty hard.
More experiences or advices are welcome
Posted 16 August 2011 - 10:18 AM
Love my Les Paul guitars, but the ES-335 can have that LP sound, and
also the mellower, warmer Semi-hollobody tone, as well. So, it's a bit
more versatile...IMHO. The ES-335 will be a bit more prone to feedback,
through the "f" holes, at high volume. But, Clapton and other's have done
well with them...even through 2 Marshall Stacks. So...???
Both guitars, are excellent! Buy one, now...save for the other one.
Posted 16 August 2011 - 10:45 AM
Gibson Left Hand SG Modified
Gibson Left Hand ES 335 Modified
Guitar Repairs, Mods & Maintenance
Black Crow Guitars
Posted 16 August 2011 - 11:04 AM
I've owned an LP since 1975 (first REAL guitar I bought brand new), and I got an ES-335 in 1980 (also a 1975 model). So I bought an LP first, and five years later found a 335 I just had to have. After getting the 335 I played it much more than the LP (gigs and rehearsals), and in fact wore the frets off it and had to replace it. I replaced it with a 345 which still gets way more playing time than the LP for Blues (mainly) and (a little) Rock. From the late 70's through the mid 90"s I also did a lot of studio work, and the LP and the ES got about equal playing time in the studio.
So having had the opportunity to own both types of guitars for many years, that's my personal summation. Doesn't really help much, does it! Good luck, you really can't go wrong with either choice, just immediately start saving up for the other one.
Posted 16 August 2011 - 03:02 PM
Gibson Les Paul Special Double Cut
Gibson Les Paul Traditional Pro (W/P-90's)
Gibson HP 665 SB
Stol Traditional Custom Built electric guitar
Guild F-212XL 12 String
Guild F-47 RC
Fender Natural Ash AmSe Telecaster
Fender Natural Ash MIM Stratocaster
Fender MIM Jazz Bass
Ovation "Cheapo" beater
Homebuilt Tele Clone
Aria Classical Guitar
ESP body/Warmouth Strat neck hybrid
Posted 16 August 2011 - 03:06 PM
Posted 17 August 2011 - 01:06 PM
I'm not specifically looking for a 'main instrument', but you can only play one guitar at once, can't you?
So, I think that if I buy a Les Paul (or an ES335) I would spend less time playing on my Stratocaster, which I really love.
It still is a though call.
I hope I'm able to visit a guitar store next week, so I can play on both the Paul and the ES335.. And I guess at that point, I have to listen to my heart and my ears.
More experiences or opinions are still welcome.
Posted 17 August 2011 - 05:40 PM
I have a 1973 Les Paul Custom, 2011 Les Paul 60's tribute, too many Fender Strats, a couple of SG'S and I recently purchased a GIBSON ES-335 Cherry Figured Top.
In my opinion as much as I would like to have the belief that 1 main go to guitar will give you genuine different guitar tone variations, I think it is a load of bull.
Between my les pauls which are worlds apart in quality & price etc...the 60's tribute is far cheaper and has tone growl!! and can be just as much fun as my 1973 LPC. It also gives you that Les Paul experience.
My ES-335 is just as versatile and is custom shop build quality. I can't put that thing down.
As I suggest like everyone else that you go to a GC and try out an ES-335, Les Paul standard/Traditional/Traditional Pro/60's Tribute.. and use that as your deciding factor.
I play in numerous bands and I would love to have the luxury of a 1 trick pony, but I just do the hard yards and drag around with me a Fender Stratocaster 3x Single Coil pups, Gibson Les Paul 60's Tribute P90's, Gibson SG 61RI 57 Classic Humbucker pups... and at present I have a Deluxe Tele coming, this is what my live performance arsenal is... You could not get any true'r tone than the original instrument designed to do that job.
How about these options;
#1 Buy an ES-335 and a Les Paul 60's tribute at the same time, this gives you more bargaining power with a GC to heavily ruduce costs...they are more than likely going to give you a bigger discount on 2x instruments than 1 alone. You not only get top of the line Custom ES-335 but also a LP60'S tribute and both will cover different tonal spectrums having ES with humbuckers and LP60'S tribute with P90's.
#2 Buy a Les Paul Traditional Pro..
#3 Talk to your muso friends and get a purchase party together for example; try to get at least 4 of your friends to buy a guitar at the same time as you. Go to a GC and put the order in for the 4x guitars. Then use this as your barganing power to purchase options 1# or #2.
Trust me you will make the GC people smile and also save yourself big dollars. It can be done as I have done it 3x.
Sorry about the war & peace.. Good Luck.
Some of My **** Man!!!!
2012 Gibson Les Paul Classic Custom Gold Top
2012 Fender Roadworn 60's Olympic White Stratocaster
2012 Fender Roadworn 50's Blonde Telecaster
2012 Epiphone Swingster Translucent Black
2011 Fender 60th Anniversary American Standard Crimson Red Telecaster
2011 Fender 60th Anniversary Blackguard Blonde Ash Telecaster
2011 Maton EM325 Acoustic Guitar
2011 Gibson Custom ES-335 with Cherry Figured Top
2011 Gibson Les Paul Studio 60's Tribute GOLD TOP
2010 Gibson SG 61 Re issue Herritage Cherry
2009 Fender American Deluxe Stratocaster Amber
2008 Fender American Standard Stratocaster 3 tone sunburst
2005 Gibson SG Standard Ebony
1976 Fender American Standard Ash Stratocaster 3 tone Sunburst
1973 Gibson Les Paul Custom Cherry Sunburst
2011 Vox AC4TV 4w 1x10 Class A Combo Amp
2010 Fender Pro Tube Twin Amp 100/25 watts
2010 Fender Blues Deluxe Reissue Tweed Covered Amp 40 watts
2009 Fender Blues Junior Amp 15 watts