Hi there, I'm about to buy a new guitar. I'm torn between the Martin CEO7 and the Gibson historic LG2 1942 banner (new, not a vintage one). I love them both, that's the problem (no, cannot buy them both, haha). Both have adirondack tops (the LG2 a 'baked' one). Which one of the two is the 'better' guitar? I know they do sound different. The Martin sounds bigger, more open and has more sustain. The Gibson sounds boxier, but also warmer and woodier imho. Again, I like them both though I find them also apples and oranges. I guess I want the guitar that has the 'oldest' sound, that sounds most like an old record if you know what I mean...though the CEO7 might have the 'best' overall quality of sound of the three, I'm afraid it will sound too hi-fi where I'm looking for a more lo-fi kinda sound...are you still with me, haha?
I need the guitar for 'small' songs how I like to call them. With some singing to go with it. Mostly fingerpicking and some strumming. Not Neil Young-like strumming. Think Tom Waits-like.
Perhaps the Gibson L00 original is also an option.
Here's the CEO7: https://youtu.be/WMbTIsqFJg8
Here's the LG2 1942 banner: https://youtu.be/kkNbG8Pl1ok
And here's the LG2 in a Tom Waits song: https://youtu.be/w8ibmF1MNnA
(That's kind of the sound I mean, can the CEO7 do that too?)
Here's the L00 original:
Please advice which one would be best for me?
Thanks!