Hi Jeff, thanks for all the info. I actually just was at Sam Ash earlier today doing this exact thing. My saddle measures out to be exactly 3 inches long though and all theirs were a bit shorter. Also, i had previously thought the current epiphone AJ series guitars for sale had the same dimension saddle as my AJ series guitar (which is older)...but it looks like epiphone must have shortened the design somewhere along the way because when I held my saddle up to the new guitars to compare...my saddle was longer. Online, I did find a Graph Tech saddle that is a full 3 inches long though with the other dimensions looking pretty close to mine too. I believe the radius even matches my original saddle. So I ordered that off amazon and will give that a shot and sand it down a bit if it needs a tweak or two to fit. I wish epiphone made it a bit easier to get original replacement parts though! Oh and for anyone with one of these older epiphone aj-200sce acoustic guitars looking for a 3 inch saddle... the Graph Tech one that i'm going to try is part number PQ-9276-C0.