Build quality consistency, is much better nowadays! As are the sheer numbers,
of choices! So, statistically speaking, you're more apt to end up with a great guitar,
now, more often than not. Some of the wood, back then, was touted to be of a "superior"
quality. But, if it didn't end up on a great guitar...that didn't mean much! I've owned guitars
since 1964...and I still have my very first "electric" guitar, which was a birthday present,
from my Mom, in 1964...my Fender "L" series Strat! Is it any better, than a new one? Who
knows? I know, TO ME, Nothing can replace it, for a variety of reasons. But, realistically,
that may be more sentimental value, to me, even way beyond it's considerable financial worth.
I have guitars, made from 1954, through 2013! I LOVE 'em ALL! If I didn't, they wouldn't
be still be here. Are they any "better" than other's in the same range, from any era?
I doubt it! But, for me, they're perfect for what I want them to do.
Now, for serious "Collectors," or those who rely more on financial "worth," than musical
viability, there's nothing I own, they'd be the least bit interested in. But, So What?!
I couldn't care less! When I'm gone, they'll be handed down, or sold off, by my survivors,
and other's will get to enjoy them.
So, "Old or New" should be evaluated on a "Case by Case" basis...IMHO. Not because it's
Old, or New!
Cheers,
CB