Jump to content
Gibson Brands Forums
Bluesy69

A Sad But True Cutting Corners Tale

Recommended Posts

Hello fellow Gibson and Les Paul lovers, and players alike.

 

I have owned many various Gibson Les Paul's in the past some I like some not so much, mostly due to the past lack of Q.C.

However more recently my friend who currently lives on disability because of his many unfortunate ailments has always dreamed of owning a Les Paul, but never had the money.

After paying off an old school loan, he found out that he could get a personal loan for the amount of $1200, which he did, and in 2018 bought himself the 2018 Gibson Les Paul Tribute model for $1099.00

Now although it's one of the lower end Gibson models it did come with a NON weight relieved body, so it was solid wood, and it had the 490r and 498t Gibson humbuckers, no eye candy like binding , flame maple or nitrocellulose shine, but a nice guitar.

 

However my friend being a traditionalist he replaced the plastic nut with a bone nut and he replaced the tone & volume pot circuit board with traditional Gibson orange drop capacitors 500's.

Now he also replaced his pickup's with Seymour Duncan's, but that's all personal preference.

 

Let's move on to the sad part.....I recently purchased an Epiphone limited edition Les Paul Custom Koa, with a SOLID, not VENEER Koa wood top and non- weight relieved mahogany body, with binding on both neck and body, and the Probucker 2 and Probucker 3 equivalent to Gibson's Burstbuckers 2 & 3, and when I got the guitar and was inspecting it, I turned the guitar over and I looked at the back, and guess what......The mahogany back was all ONE piece of solid mahogany, so to satisfy my curiosity to see if Gibson was still cutting corners on their Les Paul models I asked my friend to take a close up picture of the back of his Gibson Les Paul Tribute.

Once he emailed me the pic I magnified it, and there it was, the seam right down the middle of the back of the GIBSON guitar, they used two pieces of mahogany for his Les Paul, and I was actually angry and felt very bad for my friend who literally waited for over 30 years to be able to say he owned a Gibson Les Paul.

 

Now I know Gibson's higher end models, the standard or HP or Traditional may have the solid one piece back, but those are all well over $2500 and NO ONE should have to pay that much for a solid piece of wood, now the more uneducated or ignorant may say "oh no big deal as long as it feels and sounds good".

NO, WRONG, aside from the fact that it's how all guitars have been properly made for almost a century, it's simple physics, sound resonates better through one solid piece of wood than through two pieces glued together.

So it's obvious that if Epiphone can do it in China and Gibson in the U.S. can no longer do it, than our labor costs are just too high.

My friend the traditionalist, called Gibson himself in disbelief to confirm this and they did, they told him "yes the 2018 Les Paul Tribute model's back is made with two pieces of mahogany glued together", and to say the least he was disappointed, not outraged to my extent but disappointed, that an $1100 guitar did not come with a one piece back and my $650 guitar did, and as I said I've owned Gibson Les Paul's in the past and I would put my current Epiphone model up against any current Gibson Les Paul today, because it is aesthetically flawless and sounds and feels phenomenal, and the fact that Gibson charges SO much more for the name of Gibson without any longer producing the quality of the Gibson of old is sad and has turned me off of them until I see a major revamp in their Q.C. and materials and components.

Edited by Bluesy69

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Multiple piece backs are not an indicator of quality. In fact, if you know anything about blanks, or large slabs of wood, you would know that multiple piece backs make for stronger, longer lasting, better guitars.

 

Somewhere along the way One Piece Back Man! became the mantra for what makes a great guitar. It isn't.

 

rct

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry to hear that.

I will say though, my 2018 Tribute looks to be one piece. It only has a cap on the top, and when viewed from the sides I only see one piece, no seams.

Mine sure turned at to be an awesome player as well!

2018tributebackzm.jpg

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Multiple piece backs are not an indicator of quality. In fact, if you know anything about blanks, or large slabs of wood, you would know that multiple piece backs make for stronger, longer lasting, better guitars.

 

Somewhere along the way One Piece Back Man! became the mantra for what makes a great guitar. It isn't.

 

rct

 

 

WRONG, multiple piece backs held together by glue are not stronger than one piece backs, and even more important don't sound anywhere near as resonant as a single piece back.

 

However don't believe me, go out and glue 2 or 3 pieces of 3/4 inch ply wood together in a 1 x 2 rectangle and then get a solid one piece of the same wood thickness and size and attempt to break both over your leg and guess which one will break first and easier......the glued piece every time.

 

Plus the next time you find yourself in a guitar store find a multiple piece back guitar and a solid piece back guitar and plug each into the same setup and bend a note and see which one resonates clearer and longer...….SOLID ONE PIECE will win every time, and if you don't know that, and you consider yourself even somewhat knowledgeable in the craftsmanship of guitars, then you truly know NOTHING.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry to hear that.

I will say though, my 2018 Tribute looks to be one piece. It only has a cap on the top, and when viewed from the sides I only see one piece, no seams.

Mine sure turned at to be an awesome player as well!

2018tributebackzm.jpg

 

 

 

 

That one does not appear to have a seam, but it also does not appear to be a 2018 Tribute, it has a gloss back where my friends has the matte back.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

WRONG, multiple piece backs held together by glue are not stronger than one piece backs, and even more important don't sound anywhere near as resonant as a single piece back.

 

However don't believe me, go out and glue 2 or 3 pieces of 3/4 inch ply wood together in a 1 x 2 rectangle and then get a solid one piece of the same wood thickness and size and attempt to break both over your leg and guess which one will break first and easier......the glued piece every time.

 

Plus the next time you find yourself in a guitar store find a multiple piece back guitar and a solid piece back guitar and plug each into the same setup and bend a note and see which one resonates clearer and longer...….SOLID ONE PIECE will win every time, and if you don't know that, and you consider yourself even somewhat knowledgeable in the craftsmanship of guitars, then you truly know NOTHING.

 

Wow, you're not only inexperienced, you don't even know how to glue wood. There goes your credibility.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can believe what you want about single piece bodies..

 

But its not cutting corners in any way (in fact its more work). If they have single piece bodies they use them, if not they glue some together.. All guitar makers do that cos it doesn't make any difference.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh good God... HE'S BACK!!

 

...and off the meds...

Edited by Big Bill

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1554601046[/url]' post='1985970']

That one does not appear to have a seam, but it also does not appear to be a 2018 Tribute, it has a gloss back where my friends has the matte back.

Really man?? LOL I'm telling you this is a 2018 Gibson Les Paul Tribute. Here's the SERIAL# to it. Some are one piece and some are two piece. I believe both versions, the Honey Burst and Gold were done in a Satin nitro, not Gloss.

 

2018 Gibson Les Paul Tribute

 

 

Was just trying to be informative and helpful, thought that's why maybe you posted. Take it for what it's worth.

:)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I once built a guitar out of what was left over kitchen surface top...

 

It was awesome.. Resonated and sounded just fine thank you..

 

3VhFgfh.jpg

 

8SBqo1s.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Large wooden structural beams are laminated wood for strength!

 

I have no idea if multi wood affects tone/sustain in an electric guitar... blind test anyone?

 

If you check a few YouTube videos on Gibson factory tours, it even showed the mass production of three piece mahogany backs being glued for Les Paul backs. This was the Nashville factory.

 

 

edit: Here's one of the videos.. check 5:20 minutes

 

 

 

edit: Check out the huge wheel gluing jig... mass production gluing.

 

1:30 min

 

Edited by kaicho8888

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The real question is when Pete Townsend pops over a visit and a cup of tea do two piece backs smash the same as one piece ones?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't they glue the maple cap on???

 

Would it surprise anyone if I told him that an ES335 that costs over $3800 uses a laminated top?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is the Les Paul Tribute not weight relived?

Regarding multiply pieces of timber, bonded sections are both stronger and more stable than a single piece, it's the norm in furniture manufacture. I know that because I trained as a cabinet maker in my youth.

 

 

Ian

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If the complaint here by the OP that an Epiphone supposed “one-piece-of-wood” costs less than a Gibson “2-piece-of-wood”... who cares? I don’t.... What a stupid thing to write a frickin first-post essay about. Sorry but I know you’ve complained about stupid things in the past too. You were the guy who started my favorite 3 strikes your out Gibson thread! Haha haha! Oh man what a hoot!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If the complaint here by the OP that an Epiphone supposed "one-piece-of-wood" costs less than a Gibson "2-piece-of-wood"... who cares? I don't.... What a stupid thing to write a frickin first-post essay about. Sorry but I know you've complained about stupid things in the past too. You were the guy who started my favorite 3 strikes your out Gibson thread! Haha haha! Oh man what a hoot!

 

Wild_Bill_Hickok_by_Rockwood_1873.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tons of les Paul's have 2 piece bodoes and I even had a norlin era custom with a 3 piece top. It is no big deal and I bet you could not tell if two les Paul's were recorded with the same player and the same song if one was a 2 piece and 1 a 1 piece......could you tell the difference in tone??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

An Epi cost less cause made overseas with cheaper material by 10 year olds with no luthier experience.

Haha now that’s something to be upset about instead is a 2-piece LP - that kids are making guitars. Ughh, I miss being a kid and just worrying about going up to the park to hang with my friends to play baseball or something. Would suck if I had to report to work to make Epiphones...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Haha now that’s something to be upset about instead is a 2-piece LP - that kids are making guitars. Ughh, I miss being a kid and just worrying about going up to the park to hang with my friends to play baseball or something. Would suck if I had to report to work to make Epiphones...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...