Jump to content
Gibson Brands Forums

Flame tops vs Plain tops?


Tim Plains

Recommended Posts

So, what's your preference?

This has nothing to do with historics or non-historics.

Remember, Classics and Standards used to come in plain tops.

 

Please do not vote for my guitars, I'm just posting this for people who don't know what the difference is between a flame top and plain top. :) Maybe you guys should also post pics to help people out...

 

Plain

R8354.jpg

 

R8423.jpg

 

Flame

R9316.jpg

 

R9477.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tim or R9,

 

Whatever or whoever you are these days...Stop posting pictures of that flamed beast....Im getting all bothered!

 

GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS....

 

That said I voted Plain top....

 

A winner everytime...Eh Tim! =D>

 

Flight959

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've always been more of a plain top guy, which is why I love this so much:

<<<<<<<------------------------------

 

However, I do LOVE subtle flame tops such as this:

 

LP56HBNH-f70d6af875f5cc710823a7b840.jpg

 

I've never loved the really wide flames such as on Tim's R9, however. (R9's R9? This is SO confusing!!! Tim, why did you change your name in the first place anyway?!!! [Other than to confuse us, of course.])

 

Although that may change when (I mean, uh, if...) I get an anniversary R9.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is a tough one for me because I love both.

I must say though, that overall, I like more plain tops than I do flame tops.

Not to sound snooty, but part of that is because I have certain/high expectations for a R9s top...price driven.

A lot of the ones I've seen locally are disappointing...but then every once in a while a sweet one finds it's way to Southern Ontario...like deepblue's.

 

 

Tim or R9' date='

 

Whatever or whoever you are these days...Stop posting pictures of that flamed beast....Im getting all bothered![/quote']

OK.

 

I've never loved the really wide flames such as on Tim's R9' date=' however. (R9's R9? This is SO confusing!!! Tim, why did you change your name in the first place anyway?!!! [Other than to confuse us, of course.'])

For consistency...

 

I don't have wide flames. Do you consider these wide?

R9193.jpg

 

 

I'm a flamer and Tim likes poles* I mean polls ....

There's no comeback to this...I have nothing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I love a flat sawn plain-top when it has interesting flowing grain : flame is not essential to produce a stunning top - check out 8-6752 if you have "The Beauty of the Burst", or else 8-5489 if your tase is more extreme!.

 

My perfect top would be a flitch-matched rift-sawn with ribbon curl tiger-stripe in heavily ambered teaburst. The ex-Paul Stanley 9-1876 would fit me nicely, thank you. My birthday is next July.......

 

Having said all that I must add that the most beautiful instrument (and I don't just mean guitars) of all time (IMHO) is the 'legendary Brock/da Pra' burst (9-0913 if you must). Many thanks are due to Yasuhiko Iwanade!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...