Jump to content
Gibson Brands Forums

Chumpy36

All Access
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    8

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Posts posted by Chumpy36

    J50 Restoration. Need opinions

    in Gibson Acoustic

    Posted

    18 hours ago, duluthdan said:

    Since the first 4 frets are kind of toasty you might consider replacing them all with Evo wire or something and have the fretboard planed down or replaced as part of that task. 

    I'll let you guys know what I decide to do after talking to a few guys. 

     

    Thanks!

     

    J

    J50 Restoration. Need opinions

    in Gibson Acoustic

    Posted

    20 hours ago, Boyd said:

    The single-line tuners have a stripe in the middle that says "KLUSON" written vertically, with the oil hole in the middle of the "O".  The double-line tuners have two stripes and say "KLUSON" on the left and "DELUXE" on the right. These are some indication of date, but I gather there are overlaps during the beginning and ending of a period. I originally had the single line style tuners on my 1965 J-50, but initially could only find the double-line style which I used as replacements. Then a few years later, I finally found some of the single-line reproductions and switched to them to be more historically accurate. I gather you don't know what the original tuners were on your guitar, but if it's a 1963 then this suggests they would have been the single-line variety.

    https://www.kluson.com/faq.html

    Regarding the neck width, read my earlier post again, I don't think you understood correctly. I stated that the neck on the 2020 1960's J-50 is narrower than my 2006 J-50. The nut is the same width as my 1965 J-50 which is 1-11/16" just like yours. Although they have the same nut width, the neck on the 2020 60's J-50 is much fatter than the real 1965 J-50. All-in-all, the guitar is much more similar to my 2006 J-50 than it is to my real 1965 J-50. Will be interested to hear your impressions, as I said, I am really enjoying mine. Here's an old thread about the 60's J-50

     

    I do have the original tuners still. I'll dig them out and take a look when I get back into town. I understand now about the neck you're saying the nut width is the same but it gets fatter as. you go up the neck?

    I should have the new guitar in a few days. Will let you know. Thx for the link

     

    • Like 1

    J50 Restoration. Need opinions

    in Gibson Acoustic

    Posted

    1 hour ago, zombywoof said:

    I had the divots repaired some 12 years ago. Raising the wood fiber keeps the repaired areas from sticking out like a sore thumb and reduces the potential for uneven wear and tear down the road.  It does cost a bit more than say simply filling with sawdust and glue.  No serious plane of the neck but obviously some sanding was needed.

     

    Is it better to do a repairs like this or replace the fretboard entirely? I'm not worried about value just longevity and playability. Thanks

     

    J50 Restoration. Need opinions

    in Gibson Acoustic

    Posted

    4 hours ago, 62burst said:

    Fretboard divots are a real turnoff for me- a deep resurface of the 'board, or replacement is much preferred over filling, which almost always looks strange. Splicing in slivers externally and small cleats inside of spruce can be done for the top cracks. It might involve a slight overspray to blend, but would greatly improve their appearance. If braces need to be removed (even partially so) for that repair, the cost would jump some.  Gibson guitars have some belly to them- get your J-50 to a vintage Gibson repair shop, and see what their thoughts are.

    You are now the steward of this old guitar. The repairs that it might need aren't going to be that terrible, compared to the good you would do by getting this guitar back into a better condition for it's path going forward. It won't get any cheaper in the future. Just take it to the best shop you can find, and get yourself some good guitar karma.

     

    Thanks for the reply. I do plan to repair it. I just love it too much and I want to keep it in the family. I'm taking it to a couple a good luthiers around town to get some opinions and I've dropped a line to Gibson restoration as well. 

     

    J50 Restoration. Need opinions

    in Gibson Acoustic

    Posted

    7 hours ago, J185cat said:

    You can schedule a 15 minute zoom call with Gibson Repair and Restoration and they can give you opinions on the extent and cost. No obligation either.  Really nice service Gibson is offering now and yes, of course they are hoping to get more business from this, it’s a business!

    This is awesome advice. Thank you

    For others searching for this subject the number is at this URL 

    https://www.gibson.com/Support/Repair-And-Restoration

    J50 Restoration. Need opinions

    in Gibson Acoustic

    Posted

    9 hours ago, Boyd said:

    I have a real 1965 J-50 that is in pretty good shape. I followed prices for used ones for awhile, and they seemed to bottom out about a year ago but appear to have gone back up to pre-pandemic levels now. For example, there's a 1965 for $3100 at Guitar Center now. Guess it depends on how deep your pockets are and how much sentimental value to assign to the guitar, looks pretty ugly in your pictures. Don't think I'd put much into it myself.

    The original tuners on mine were very stiff and I spent awhile doing all the recommended things to recondition them but still wasn't happy. WD Music Products bought the Kluson name and all of their old designs. They make very accurate looking replicas that work well, they should fit the original holes with no "plugging". Here's an example, but these are the "double line" style and I wanted "single line" to match the originals which I had to shop around to find

    https://www.wdmusic.com/kluson-3-on-a-plate-supreme-series-tuning-machines-details.html

    I just got a 2020 60's Original J-50 and really like it so far. But it's quite different from a real vintage J-50. The neck is  more narrow than my 2006 J-50 with a nut that is the same width as my 1965 J-50. However, it is much thicker than the real 1965 J-50, and by the time you get to the 4th fret the circumference is the same as the 2006 J-50. It has Grover replicas of the original Kluson 3-on-a-plate tuners that look good and operate well. Not sure if you can buy these separately.

    I've got some money to spend and the guitar is important to me as it came from family and I want the guitar preserved for my son or anyone who can use it and appreciate it. I'd hate to scrap it. 

    Thanks for the link to the Klusons, maybe those will be better than the allparts ones I tried. Not sure what single line is vs double?
     

    I just picked up a 2020 60's Original J-50 LAST NIGHT! Waiting on it from a Sam Ash store in Tx. I'm surprised the neck is NARROWER than this one as it's pretty darn narrow. The nut width on mine is 1 11/16 so I guess that means it's before 65? Best guess I could get from serial number is 63. 

    Thanks for the reply

    J50 Restoration. Need opinions

    in Gibson Acoustic

    Posted

    Hi all,

     

    I came by this guitar (best guess is a 1963) from my wife's uncle. It has been terribly mistreated. It was apparently stored down in a basement for years next to a furnace or radiator and has obviously had a lot of issues because of it. I decided to take a stab out of making it a player because I loved the idea of having a vintage guitar I could actually play. First Luthier I think did a pretty good job. The issues were...

    1. Loose bracing

    2. Bridge pulling up (see side pics)

    3. Remove weird plastic rosette someone had put there to protect from strumming damage

    4. Straighten wavy gravy pickguard and reglue
    5. Replace bridge with non adjustable bridge and setup
    6. Remove janky 1/4" plug someone drilled into side of the guitar

    The idea was this would get it to playable condition and it would let me decide whether I wanted to spend more to get it right or just keep it as a heirloom. I've decided I REALLY like the sound of it and want to continue playing it. I decided to keep the custom teenage artwork on the front as a part of the guitar's story even though I don't love it. 

    Continuing issues.

    1. There's a pretty big belly on the guitar. Not sure if this can ever be fixed but the repair guy compensated and the action is awesome. I was warned it might be a good idea to use light strings
    2. The rosette still has some structural issues and could prolly be shored up. 
    3. While replacing the strap button with a straplock button the heel block cracked off (even though I used the same screw). I glued it back but there's a line that looks unsightly (see pics)
    4. Considerable fretwear on the first 4 frets
    5. Considerable scalloping of the fretboard in the first 4 frets
    6. Top continues to crack even though I've been careful to keep it humidified. I'm not sure if it a problem with the belly below the bridge or something else but there's a new crack I diascovered this week
    7. The tuners aren't great. I removed the original because several were very stiff and replaced it with a set of allparts aged vintage set which look good but still aren't very accurate, since it's a frankenstein I wonder if plugging the holes and putting Grover or something else on there might make sense?


    I guess what I'm asking is WWGGFD? Would you spend the money (if these problems can even be fixed? I don't know that they can be) to get it into stable playing shape? The other option is to just stop and play it occasionally and admire it. I plan to get another J-50 (prolly the 60's original version) to play out with etc. But I'd kind of hate to never play this one again. 

    Pics are here: The first four are how I received the guitar the rest are post first round of repairs.

    https://imgur.com/a/OmK20Jz

    Thoughts?

×
×
  • Create New...