I am a fan. You don't have to like it, or even agree but there is a pretty bullet-proof argument to be made that Noel Gallagher is the greatest songwriter of the last 30 or so years, and quite easily. Cobain comes in at second. The songwriting is what matters, not some pentatonic wankery.
"I consider Noel Gallagher to be the finest songwriter of his generation." - Those are the words of Sir George Martin, remember that guy? Produced Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band amongst some other albums and tracks for that little Beatles band? You know that record? With 'A Day In The Life' and a few other tunes? Lennon at his absolute peak, McCartney too. All overseen by George Martin. Given George worked in such close proximity to the two GOAT songwriters for a period of 9 years or so - at their absolute zenith - i'd say he knows a thing or two about melody and songwriting talent. Maybe more so than most in that regard. In Sir George's assessment Noel is right up there and anyone with a functioning set of ears and an honest heart would, i would say, be inclined to agree. Hack guitarists out there are a dime a dozen, Noel's songwriting and melodicism is a one in a million talent. More like one in a billion. I'd love to hear some critics efforts at songwriting and singing. Point me to some songs i'll listen with an open heart. If anyone can do better than 'Champagne Supernova' or 'Wonderwall' then have at it and rake in the millions. Something tells me they don't, not because they won't but because they can't. Noely G. has done alright following his own intuition as opposed to listening to the laughable 'guidance' of a few internet trolls.
Can't wait to pick up one of these Rivieras! Long overdue!