Jump to content
Gibson Brands Forums

Dave F

All Access
  • Posts

    5,177
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    12

Posts posted by Dave F

  1. Visibly the EIR will be riddled with spores where the BRW will be significantly less. If you can get some shavings, you can do the fluorescent and buoyancy test. You could lightly sand on the inside of the guitar. The BRW has a very distinct aroma.  They do have a visible color difference but that can be misleading.  I educated myself a few years ago by getting samples of each and a 10x magnifier when I started shopping around for an older Martin BRW.

    Distinguishing Brazilian From East Indian Rosewood – The Luthier Bench

     

  2. I bought one of the new '42 Banner SJ in 2020. It's one of my favorites. I really think the baked top adds to the sound and brings out that rosewood sound. I don't think it sounds like one from the '40's but maybe from the '50's. I like the neck, not too big, not too small.

    I've bought my last couple guitars from Music Villa and they've been very easy to work a deal with.

    Here it is neck to a Legend and a '52 J45

    50561472611_2545c6c7dd_w.jpg

     

    • Like 1
  3. I’ve had a few newer Smecks that were 1.81. 
    I have a new Martin that is 1.81. 
    I have a Taylor nylon that is 1.875

    I’ve never had a 1.875 steel guitar except for a 12 string. 

  4. I like variety. A few weeks ago a Gibson '06 L4A arrived (think J185CE). This week a new Martin 0012-28 Modern Deluxe. I have most sizes covered from 00 to Super 400.

    FullSizeRender_754073ad-48bf-466b-b3b5-5

    You have a Martin 16" dread and a Gibson 16" dread. Venture out a little bit. You shouldn't rule out the used market. If you find one you like but want to get a new one, it will be easy to move the used one. I did that with the 000-28EC. Bought it used, liked it, sold it, bought a new 000-28EC SB.

    53976251528_9b47e900e7_b.jpg

    I just bought a L4A off Ebay for $760. Not new but in great shape. There are bargains out there if you're patient.

    s-l1600.webp

     

    • Like 1
  5. 29 minutes ago, 62burst said:

    That was funny. I chose to laugh, rather than get offended.

    That was the intent but sometimes I need to curb my humor. When I saw the white mustache, the Hulk was the first thing that popped in my head. I definitely like my Martins. I have a new 0012-28 Modern Deluxe due any day. No graphics. I'm still going to vote.

    My brother met him last week 

    53969875895_7d939172ac_b.jpg

     

    • Like 1
  6. 54 minutes ago, jt said:

    Oh, my. A preference for a fake wrestler over a brilliant musician. I don't care about politics when deciding the artists I embrace. And, well, when I'm considering the merits of artists, I don't include fake wrestlers. Sigh.

    In reality, I wouldn't buy either one. I think the only two Martin guitars with graphics that I've ever consider buying was the Louvin Brothers and the Fly Fisherman.

    card_D-28-Louvin-Brothers_f.jpg?sw=600&stds6tumnmc0dirmmuxc3.jpg

     

  7. 37 minutes ago, JimR56 said:

    As I mentioned in the other thread about this guitar (in the Vintage forum), I'm not a flat-top expert, but the pickguard on this one struck me as being a bit different in shape from what I would have expected.  Do any of you guys with more experience with flat-tops have any thoughts about the pickguard?  I tried to enlarge the photo to get a better idea of the material, but found that difficult.  Anyway, just curious whether it's original, or maybe custom ordered (?), or perhaps a replacement.

    Here' a '41 that sold on reverb and one from True vintage. The OP's looks a little different but the last one from HQ looks the same.

    1941 Gibson J-100 | Reverb (bing.com)

    d9esn55jld2ydvhyk6kz.jpg

    Vintage 1941 Gibson Super Jumbo 100 acoustic guitar – True Vintage Guitar

    DSC_3180_f3491856-6b80-4d01-a502-0da0ef0

    Gibson SJ-100 guitar Gibson J-100 guitar Gibson J100 guitar Super Jumbo 100 guitar info vintage 1939 to 1943 (guitarhq.com)

    40j100.jpg

     

     

     

     

    • Like 1
  8. Nice guitar! The site Jim mentioned is a great resource. Per it, the FON is 1940 but the bridge features start in 1941, so this is probably somewhere in between that crossover. You may want to repost this in the Acoustic section.

  9. The 'newer 42 Banner SJ I got a few years ago came with Kluson repos on it. I did not care for them and put a set of Waverly's on it.  I replaced the tuners on my '42 LG1 with Stewmac Golden Age. I have quite a few sets of vintage tuners if it needs to go back to original.

    CSRSSJ42VS_hs_back.png?w=1200&h=1200

    Tiger stripe

     

    42 LG1

     

    52649845278_e99123b7ec_b.jpg

     

     

  10. Some of the Banner SJ did have the individual tuners. I think your tuners may be era correct.

    Willi has a thread on UMGF about tuners

    Chronology of Kluson tuners used from late 1936 to 1946 on J-35s, L-0/00, J-45/50s, LGs, SJs - The Unofficial Martin Guitar Forum (umgf.com)

    Here's your 2 picts and one from the thread that shows your tuners on a '43 SJ

     If you want a set of vintage 3 on a plate, let me know and I'll fix you up.

     

    QH1oOhI.jpeg

     

    cnk7iA9.jpeg

    888487_e26a5db1d1f0064f222ccfc7e6f498f0_

     

×
×
  • Create New...