Hawkesman Posted May 14, 2017 Share Posted May 14, 2017 This just popped into my inbox... https://reverb.com/n...cepts-explained Why the downer on tuning with harmonics? Whatever the 'physics' may be, I've tuned the same way for 30+ years. I've always set the intonation by ear, and in latter years I have occasionally checked it with a tuner, but I rarely have to change anything, and then not by much. I then tune by using the 5th and 7th fret harmonics to tune the E, A, D & G strings. I then use the A string 7th fret harmonic to tune the high E, then use 5th and 7th fret harmonics to tune the B to the high E. My simple end-check is to play an open E chord at the 13/14 frets and make sure there is no 'phase'. It works perfectly, and players that I work with have often commented that my tuning is always spot-on. Any thoughts/views? H. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
glp2012 Posted May 14, 2017 Share Posted May 14, 2017 Here's my thought...you have 30+ years of experience and the guy that wrote the article doesn't. I watched a YouTube video with Joe Walsh showing you how to tune the guitar. According to him, he has perfect pitch and doesn't need a tuner. His advice always tune up to the note! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hawkesman Posted May 14, 2017 Author Share Posted May 14, 2017 His advice always tune up to the note! +1 to that! I still occasionally see people tuning down, but I've now learned to grit my teeth and STFU. Unless it's in the studio! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rct Posted May 14, 2017 Share Posted May 14, 2017 This just popped into my inbox... https://reverb.com/n...cepts-explained Why the downer on tuning with harmonics? Whatever the 'physics' may be, I've tuned the same way for 30+ years. I've always set the intonation by ear, and in latter years I have occasionally checked it with a tuner, but I rarely have to change anything, and then not by much. I then tune by using the 5th and 7th fret harmonics to tune the E, A, D & G strings. I then use the A string 7th fret harmonic to tune the high E, then use 5th and 7th fret harmonics to tune the B to the high E. My simple end-check is to play an open E chord at the 13/14 frets and make sure there is no 'phase'. It works perfectly, and players that I work with have often commented that my tuning is always spot-on. Harmonics begin sharp, tuning quickly to harmonics like we did in the 70's to keep the gig moving was bad, resulted in guitars poorly intonated from one song to another and somewhat out of tune with each other. We don't play harmonics, we play open notes, fretted notes, and combinations of the two. That's about the best reason not to tune with harmonics. You can use beats to help intonate, but getting a guitar intonated for the most part all over the neck, for the most part, requires something that hears things we can't hear. rct Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hawkesman Posted May 14, 2017 Author Share Posted May 14, 2017 Perhaps so, but tuning is, as we all know, not an exact science, it is a compromise. No neck has 'perfect' fret placement, so, to me, using an electronic device instead of one's ears will not allow the human factor to temper these variances and achieve the best overall result. IMHO. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rct Posted May 14, 2017 Share Posted May 14, 2017 Perhaps so, but tuning is, as we all know, not an exact science, it is a compromise. No neck has 'perfect' fret placement, so, to me, using an electronic device instead of one's ears will not allow the human factor to temper these variances and achieve the best overall result. IMHO. Fair enough. Nobody wants to hear your harmonics. That's the last answer that I didn't put up there, and to me, as a guy that did that for decades, the best reason to use a tuner. Nobody wants to hear you tuning. rct Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hawkesman Posted May 14, 2017 Author Share Posted May 14, 2017 Fair enough. Nobody wants to hear your harmonics. Nobody wants to hear you tuning. rct Why? It's just a part of what happens when I play with people, and I'm used to it. Also, I just checked the intonation on my SG, then tuned it in my usual 'harmonics' way. I then did something which, oddly, I'd never done before and checked it with my tuner. It was spot-on. Oh well, each to their own I guess! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hawkesman Posted May 14, 2017 Author Share Posted May 14, 2017 Oh, and sorry about the last series of Sherlock. I quite enjoyed it, but I know not everyone did! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rct Posted May 14, 2017 Share Posted May 14, 2017 Why? It's just a part of what happens when I play with people, and I'm used to it. Also, I just checked the intonation on my SG, then tuned it in my usual 'harmonics' way. I then did something which, oddly, I'd never done before and checked it with my tuner. It was spot-on. Oh well, each to their own I guess! Oh sure, between friends absolutely. But not in a bar. rct Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
surfpup Posted May 14, 2017 Share Posted May 14, 2017 Tuning a guitar is never perfect. It's a compromise. Whether you are fretting or using harmonics, you will slowly sharpen up as you proceed to the higher strings. Always cross check with lower strings. That said a tuner is more accurate than your ear no matter who you are. Modern tuners even have sweetened tunings to compensate for the finger pressure on the fat strings. Most people do this naturally after enough years of playing. Ever tuned up then noticed you clamp down an open G chord and the root note is sharp? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rct Posted May 14, 2017 Share Posted May 14, 2017 Oh, and sorry about the last series of Sherlock. I quite enjoyed it, but I know not everyone did! It was rough. They could have done so much more, so much better. I hope they can find time to make one offs here and there. Those seem to be the best. It went really well through out, got weak when they started trying to tie up the whole Mrs John Watson intrigue, and man, the last three were awful. We just got the Victorian Slum show. Pretty good stuff! rct Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hawkesman Posted May 14, 2017 Author Share Posted May 14, 2017 Oh sure, between friends absolutely. But not in a bar. rct Yeah - fair point. Trouble is my eyesight has got so bad I can't see the bloody readout unless it's within 2 feet of my nose! But I guess the original point I was trying to make is that tuning with harmonics works fine if you know what you are doing. That's all. Cheers, H Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dennis G Posted May 15, 2017 Share Posted May 15, 2017 Here's my thought...you have 30+ years of experience and the guy that wrote the article doesn't. ...Joe Walsh showing you how to tune the guitar...His advice always tune up to the note! This (tune UP to the note) Tuning a guitar is never perfect. It's a compromise...That said a tuner is more accurate than your ear no matter who you are. And this. My 2 cents, anyway. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Megafrog Posted May 15, 2017 Share Posted May 15, 2017 I have been playing for 35 years and back in the day I would tune via harmonics. I now use a variety of tuners from Snarks to chromatic pedals and when I attempt to tune by harmonics and compare, I am usually off by a bit on the G, B and E strings. Maybe I am just going deaf. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hawkesman Posted May 15, 2017 Author Share Posted May 15, 2017 I have been playing for 35 years and back in the day I would tune via harmonics. I now use a variety of tuners from Snarks to chromatic pedals and when I attempt to tune by harmonics and compare, I am usually off by a bit on the G, B and E strings. Maybe I am just going deaf. Yes - but after you've done it manually, does it sound right, all over the fretboard, regardless of what the machines say? Accuracy, precision? I genuinely don't believe that these terms can apply to an instrument that can only be imperfect, however well-made. Hence my faith in the 'human factor' first, and machines second. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Retired Posted May 15, 2017 Share Posted May 15, 2017 As a 13 year old learning to play I was taught to use your ear. Did that through my 20's and I got pretty close or good enough as I just played at home. It always sounded good and I checked it with a E, A & D chord. But bought my first tuner at age 60 and I loved it. Use it all the time and it's so much quicker. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MichaelT Posted May 15, 2017 Share Posted May 15, 2017 Fair enough. Nobody wants to hear your harmonics. That's the last answer that I didn't put up there, and to me, as a guy that did that for decades, the best reason to use a tuner. Nobody wants to hear you tuning. rct Ah, the Ancient Chinese Art of Tu Ning. Or to badly quote something else: On stage, everyone can hear you tune. I definitely like my Snark SN-10S tuner. Big bright letters that I can see close up and afar, cuts off the sound to the amp should I need to tune and seems to be pretty accurate for normal stage/practice use. I know people that use the harmonic tuning but I rarely have. For quick tuning, I'll usually just play an E or G open chord and tune up, or down then up. I've seen/heard Hendrix tune up on stage, full volume, but he didn't have these kinds of things available in his day and he was also quick about it. There's a lively discussion further down the page discussing tuning with harmonics. Does anyone remember tuning with a tuning fork or pitch pipe? I wish I still had mine, just for fun. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
deeman Posted May 15, 2017 Share Posted May 15, 2017 Oh sure, between friends absolutely. But not in a bar. rct Agreed, when I'm jamming it doesn't bother me to hear people tuning, but if I'm watching a band live I do not want to hear them tuning. Just mute the damn thing and use a pedal tuner and get off my lawn! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kidblast Posted May 15, 2017 Share Posted May 15, 2017 Tuning never has been and never will be something where it's absolute perfection. For every one theory that's out there, three disprove it. That "argument" with the comments in the article posted was childish. Basically what I tell (well used to tell) my students when they'd ask "What's wrong with this".. (most of the time, nothing really major). Just use your tuner to get as close as you can, use your ears to compensate for what ever one of the many quirks your guitar may have. (a poorly cut nut, off intonation, old cruddy strings, what ever...) not exactly stuff rockets are made from. are there exceptions when something is actually OFF and needs to be addressed? of course... but often times, it's just lack of patience, and not understanding the physics are not, never will be perfect. in music, everything winds up being a compromise at some point in time. just my 2-cents, like they're important right? And,, don't know what's worse, some one oblivious and bangin away on a guitar that isn't tuned, or me listening while they're tuning it... the ever so popular clip on tuners need nothing more than the vibrations off the headstock. (pssst... we know you're using em, we seem on your headstock.. so y'all can just trun down your volume, tune that suckah... and you'll at least be closer to being in tune, we wont want to slice our wrists, and at the end of the day... we'll all be happier.) Then there's acoustic pianos that haven't been tuned since "W" was president....... oh the horrrrrrrrrrrrorrrrrrrs.. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Versatile Posted May 15, 2017 Share Posted May 15, 2017 Spare a thought for little old moi....:blink: A 12 string is the biggest challenge to 'compromise tune' with..... Starting with open chords....reasonably OK.... Capo 5th requires thick 6th,5th and 4th detuning.....both 2nd's out differently.... Back to open....reverse former adjustments.... No time to faff with a tuner....done by ear with joke patter to entertain..... Beginning to consider taking 2 guitars around to ease the burden.... V Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
american cheez Posted May 15, 2017 Share Posted May 15, 2017 clip on tuners are garbage. i know it's a fad right now, but so was the pet rock once upon a time. they're ok if you wanna sing kumbaya around the campfire with some old acoustic. aside from that, they suck. try using one in a noisy situation and the interference drives them a little batty. besides, pedal tuners also work as a mute, some have signal buffers built into them too. the best bang for your buck, inexpensive, lasts forever, accurate as they get until you get a rack tuner, and you can strum all 6 strings at once, and see individually which ones are sharp/flat and deal only with those. oh, and easily readable even by guys as blind as me, in any light situation one might encounter: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hawkesman Posted May 16, 2017 Author Share Posted May 16, 2017 That "argument" with the comments in the article posted was childish. Huh? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kidblast Posted May 16, 2017 Share Posted May 16, 2017 referring to the COMMENTS following the article. did you read them? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Farnsbarns Posted May 16, 2017 Share Posted May 16, 2017 The harmonics are pure notes. They don't actually feature in our modern tempered scale so you'll be out of tune with other instruments (quite apart from the inherent inaccuracies of tuning fretted stringed instruments). Tune to them, by all means, but be aware they're the wrong note, actually by a fair amount. Edit: I do sometimes tune to harmonics if I have no tuner because cancelling out the phasing is easier than actually matching pitch in a noisy environment and the notes can be ringing while turning the machine head, but I usually find myself tweaking a string or two as soon as I start playing. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
saturn Posted May 16, 2017 Share Posted May 16, 2017 Just listen to JT B) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.